Wholesale Distribution
November 16, 2026
8 min

What a workers' compensation mod above 1.10 costs a Georgia distributor, and what moves it before the next renewal

A 1.10 mod costs a mid-size Georgia distributor $11,000 to $48,000 a year, for three ratings. The split point, the 30 percent rule, and four actions that move it before renewal.

Key finding
A workers' compensation mod of 1.10 costs a mid-size Georgia wholesale distributor roughly $11,000 to $48,000 a year in premium that peers with average loss experience do not pay, and because each policy year sits in three consecutive mods, the year that produced it costs about three times that before it leaves the calculation.

Georgia's workers' compensation loss costs fell 8.8 percent on 1 March 2026. For a $25M to $200M wholesale distributor in Atlanta or anywhere in Georgia, the experience modification factor now decides more of the workers' compensation bill than the rate does, and it is the only part of the calculation the company controls.

What an experience mod is

The experience modification factor, or mod, is a multiplier that NCCI calculates for each employer above a premium threshold and that carriers apply to the base premium (the manual premium, before the mod). It compares the company's actual workers' compensation losses over a three-year window with the losses expected for a company of its payroll, class codes and state. A mod of 1.00 is average. A 1.10 mod adds ten percent to premium; a 1.25 mod adds twenty-five.

What the mod signals, and to whom

The premium is the smaller consequence. The mod travels with every workers' compensation quote and renewal, and underwriters read a figure above roughly 1.10 as an operational problem and above 1.25 as a reason to decline or restrict. In a sale or a refinancing, the buyer's or lender's insurance diligence reads the three-year mod trend as a proxy for safety culture. And the lag runs the wrong way: today's mod reflects policy years that began two to four years ago, so injuries prevented this year do not show in the number until 2028.

The number, and why it is larger than it looks

Illustrative distributorBase premiumMod 1.10, per yearMod 1.25, per yearOver three ratings (1.10)
$40M revenue, $5M payroll$110,000$11,000$27,500$33,000
$90M revenue, $11M payroll$240,000$24,000$60,000$72,000
$180M revenue, $22M payroll$480,000$48,000$120,000$144,000

Illustration. Base premium assumes a blended rate near $2.20 per $100 of payroll for a mixed warehouse, driver, sales and office workforce after the March 2026 Georgia loss-cost decrease; a specific company's rate can fall anywhere from roughly $1.50 to $3.00 depending on class mix and carrier. Dollar effects scale directly with base premium.

Two things make the true cost larger than one year's figure suggests. First, the mod is not a one-year event. The losses that produced it stay in the rating window for three consecutive ratings, so a company that absorbs a 1.10 mod this year is usually looking at a similar figure for two more renewals unless the underlying claims are corrected or closed. Second, the March 2026 loss-cost decrease lowers the expected losses in the formula as well as the rate. All else equal, a company whose own claims did not fall with the state average will see its mod rise even as its rate falls, because the comparison got harder.

Four terms the worksheet uses

Split point. The dollar amount at which NCCI divides each claim into a primary layer and an excess layer. Losses below the split point count in full in the mod formula; losses above it count at a fraction set by the company's size. Since the 2024 plan revision each state has its own split point. Georgia's is $21,500.

State accident limitation. The maximum amount of any single claim, or all claims from one accident, that enters the mod. Since 2024 NCCI sets it at roughly the 95th percentile of each state's lost-time claims, so the largest claims are capped before the formula sees them.

Experience rating adjustment (ERA). The NCCI rule that reduces medical-only claims, those with no wage-replacement payment, to 30 percent of their value in the mod calculation. It exists so that employers are not penalized for reporting small injuries, and it is the reason return-to-work within the waiting period matters so much.

Valuation date. The date on which the carrier reports each policy year's losses to NCCI for the mod, 18 months after that policy year began, with later updates at 30 and 42 months. Claims are reported at their reserve as of that date, so an open claim counts at what the adjuster expects it to cost, not what it eventually costs.

Why a distributor's mod moves on small claims, not large ones

Georgia's split point divides every claim into a primary layer, which counts in full, and an excess layer above it, which counts at a fraction. The split point was set at $21,500 when NCCI revised the plan in 2024, and it is still $21,500 on worksheets for ratings effective at the end of 2026.

The arithmetic is the part most executives have never seen. Five lifting-injury claims of $12,000 each put $60,000 into the primary layer. One $400,000 forklift claim puts $21,500 into the primary layer and the rest into the discounted excess layer, capped by the state's per-claim limit. The five small claims hurt the mod roughly one and a half to three times as much as the one catastrophic claim, depending on company size.

Two further rules reward speed. A claim that stays medical-only, with no wage replacement, enters the calculation at 30 percent of its value under NCCI's experience rating adjustment. In Georgia, wage replacement begins after a seven-day waiting period, so an injured warehouse worker who is back on modified duty within a week usually keeps the claim in that 30 percent category. And every claim is valued at its reserve, not its eventual paid amount, on the valuation date 18 months after the policy year began. An open claim carrying a stale $45,000 reserve counts as $45,000 even if it closes at $9,000 a month later.

Working the formula for companies in this band, ORA estimates that roughly $25,000 to $60,000 of additional primary losses across the three-year window moves the mod by about 0.10. That is two or three indemnity claims.

How to read the worksheet: a step-by-step guide

The experience rating worksheet is the short NCCI document behind the number. Most run two to four pages: a summary page, then one block for each policy year. A controller can work through it in about an hour.

  1. Get the worksheet. Ask the carrier or NCCI for the current experience rating worksheet and the two before it. Three in a row show the trend and make a change in any one year easy to spot.
  2. Read the summary page. It shows the rating effective date, the state split point, and two sets of figures side by side: expected losses for a company of this payroll and class mix, and the company's actual losses. Each is divided into a primary portion and an excess portion. The mod at the bottom of the page is the actual total divided by the expected total.
  3. Read each policy-year block. There is one block for each of the three years in the window. Each lists the class codes, the payroll in each code, the expected loss rate and discount ratio for that code, and then the claims: each claim's incurred amount, its primary amount, and whether it is open or closed. Claims of $2,000 or less are grouped into a single line for the year.
  4. Check the claims. Every claim should be this company's, on this policy. A closed claim should show what was actually paid, not an old reserve. An open claim should carry a reserve the adjuster can explain today. Recoveries from a third party should be reflected.
  5. Check the payroll and the dates. Payroll should sit in the right class codes: warehouse payroll coded as driver payroll, or office payroll coded as warehouse, distorts the expected losses the company is measured against. The three years shown should be the three that ended at least a year before the rating date, and a year that has dropped out of the window should not still be there.
  6. File corrections through the carrier. The carrier submits corrected data to NCCI, and NCCI recalculates and reissues the mod. Put the request in writing, name the claim or the payroll line, and attach the support.

Spring renewal, autumn renewal: why the calendar matters

The valuation date drives the timing of everything a company can do. For a distributor with a 1 April renewal, the newest policy year in the next mod is the one that began two Aprils earlier, and it is valued the preceding October. The six months before that October are the window to close claims and right-size reserves; after it, the year is fixed for that rating. For a 1 October renewal the same logic puts the window in the spring. The March 2026 loss-cost decrease adds a second timing effect: because expected losses in the formula fall with the filing, a company whose own claim experience is flat will see its mod drift upward at its first rating after 1 March 2026, with no change in what happened on its dock.

How a distributor compares with its neighbors

Nondurable-goods wholesalers (beverage, food, chemicals, paper) recorded 3.0 injuries per 100 full-time workers in 2024, against 1.7 for durable-goods wholesalers (building materials, industrial supply, auto parts) and 4.6 for warehousing and storage. A 150-person nondurable distributor should expect four to five recordable injuries a year, roughly two with days away from work. Fewer than that, and the mod falls on its own within three ratings; more, and no premium negotiation will offset it.

What moves the number before the next renewal

  1. Read the worksheet. Ask the carrier for the experience rating worksheet and work through the guide above. Check that every claim is the company's, that closed claims show what was paid, and that payroll sits in the right class codes. Errors are corrected through the carrier.
  2. Work open claims before they are counted. Claims are counted at the adjuster's reserve about six months before renewal. Before that date, review every open claim with the adjuster, close what can close, and get stale reserves updated to what the claim will actually cost.
  3. Get injured workers back within a week. A written modified-duty policy, a supervisor who calls the injured worker the same day, and a clinic that knows the company's light-duty options keep most strains and sprains medical-only, where they count at 30 percent. For a distributor this is the largest controllable lever in the formula.
  4. Count the small injuries. Small claims sit almost entirely in the primary layer, where they count in full. Track the count every month against the benchmark above: four to five recordable injuries a year for a 150-person food or beverage distributor. Fewer, and the mod falls on its own.

The first two can change the mod at the next renewal and take a controller an afternoon. The last two lower it over the three renewals that follow.

Sources: NCCI, Summary of the Proposed Georgia Workers Compensation Loss Cost and Rate Filing, effective 1 March 2026; NCCI, Experience Rating Plan Methodology Update filing summary and FAQs; NCCI Georgia experience rating worksheet, rating effective 31 December 2026 (split point $21,500); NCCI State of the Line 2026, as reported by Insurance Journal, 14 May 2026; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Survey of Occupational Injuries and Illnesses, 2024; O.C.G.A. §34-9-220. Dollar illustrations and the $25,000 to $60,000 estimate are ORA's own, derived from the NCCI formula, and should be read as ranges.

This piece is educational and general in nature; it is not advice about any specific company's insurance program and does not solicit the replacement of any agent or broker.

How much does a 1.10 experience mod cost a $25M to $200M Georgia wholesale distributor?

Roughly $11,000 to $48,000 a year in workers' compensation premium, depending on payroll and class mix, and about three times that over the three ratings the bad year stays in.

Why does a workers' compensation mod stay high for three years?

Each policy year's losses sit in three consecutive mods, so the claims that raised the mod keep raising it until that year drops out of the window.

What is Georgia's experience rating split point, and why do small claims matter more than large ones?

Georgia's split point is $21,500. Losses below it count in full and losses above it at a fraction, so several small claims put more into the formula than one large claim.

How does the 2026 Georgia loss-cost decrease affect an experience mod?

It lowers the expected losses in the formula as well as the rate, so a company whose own claims did not fall with the state average sees its mod rise even as its rate falls.

What can a distributor do before renewal to lower its experience mod?

Audit the worksheet, close and right-reserve open claims before the valuation date, keep claims medical-only through return-to-work within seven days, and reduce the count of small injuries.

How do injury rates for beverage, food and building-products distributors compare?

In 2024 nondurable-goods wholesalers recorded 3.0 injuries per 100 full-time workers, durable-goods wholesalers 1.7, and warehousing and storage 4.6.